👉 Engineering criticism, or "critical engineering," is a contentious approach in the field of software engineering that emphasizes the importance of constructive, technical feedback aimed at improving code quality and development processes. Critics argue that this method can sometimes be perceived as overly technical or even abrasive, potentially demotivating developers and creating a toxic work environment. The core criticism is that while the intent is to foster better code and processes, the manner in which this feedback is delivered can undermine team morale and collaboration. Effective engineering criticism should focus on specific, actionable points that enhance the code and development practices without resorting to personal attacks or overly technical jargon, striking a balance between rigor and respect.
